A V D L

A V D LA V D LA V D L
Home
Project Formulation
Collaboration Plan
Ideation &Validation Plan
Methodology & Features
Testing & Results
Implications &Future Work
Applicable Standards
Sources

A V D L

A V D LA V D LA V D L
Home
Project Formulation
Collaboration Plan
Ideation &Validation Plan
Methodology & Features
Testing & Results
Implications &Future Work
Applicable Standards
Sources
More
  • Home
  • Project Formulation
  • Collaboration Plan
  • Ideation &Validation Plan
  • Methodology & Features
  • Testing & Results
  • Implications &Future Work
  • Applicable Standards
  • Sources
  • Home
  • Project Formulation
  • Collaboration Plan
  • Ideation &Validation Plan
  • Methodology & Features
  • Testing & Results
  • Implications &Future Work
  • Applicable Standards
  • Sources

Project Formulation





STAKEHOLDER ANALYSIS

The primary stakeholders for our project include the US military and Humanitarian Efforts (such as the United Nations Mine Action Service (UNMAS), United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), APOPO (Scent detection animals), The HALO Trust, etc.). While Humanitarian Demining Groups are our main stakeholders, the military also plays an important role in demining efforts and our solution obtains the potential of eliminating risks to military personnel and/or dogs in mine fields. Additionally, we have secondary stakeholders such as the civilian that live near or in these mine-filled countries since they are also affected by this worldwide issue and have their own inputted efforts into demining.


Market Need

  • Currently, there are about 110 million planted landmines throughout the world awaiting destruction [2]. 
  • Mines can be made for as little as $3, but their removal can cost up to $1000; it would cost $50-100 billion to remove all existing mines [2].
  • Countries in massive danger of anti-personnel mines include but not limited to Egypt (23 million mines), Angola (9-15 million mines), Iran (16 million mines), Afghanistan (10 million mines), and Iraq (10 million mines) [2].
  • More than 7,000 casualties were reported by the Landmine Monitor for the year 2020, significantly outnumbering the 5,554 casualties reported in 2019. [3] (It must be emphasized that only a small percentage of landmine victims actually make it to medical facilities; according to ICRC doctors, up to 50% of mine patients die immediately after the explosion. [1])
  • Additionally, the Landmine Monitor recorded over 45 deminer casualties in 2018, one of them being a demining dog that was killed in a mine explosion in Turkey [4]
  • There is an evident need to halt landmine production/manufacturing and increase demining efforts across all countries while minimizing costs.

Military

  • Trained military personnel and dog deminers are being killed every year.
  • Explosive detecting dogs can be unreliable due to unpredictable habits from dog and/or environment
  • Most advanced mine detection methods still rely on the use of a physical operator person, creating dangerous environment

Humanitarian Efforts

  1. Thousands of innocent civilians and children are killed by anti-personnel mines annually

  • Conventional methods for mine detection, such as poking and metal detection, are unreliable and dangerous
  • Some humanitarian groups lack the required resources to attain advanced mine detection technology, thus rely on old, dangerous, and inefficient mine detecting methods

Other Stakeholders:


                                            

Other Stakeholders

.

BREAKING DOWN THE PROBLEM

The most common methods of detecting anti-personnel mines today include the use of metal/GPR sensor devices, trained animals, or large military vehicles. However, the mentioned methods of detecting landmines mostly involve the use of a human operator (with or without an animal) constantly exposing his/her life to accidental detonation of a mine; contrastingly, the use of military tanks does not cause danger to any human operators, but it does create an unrepairable amount of damage to the soil/environment in which the mines are placed in, therefore making the environment useless for future construction, farming, etc. Additionally, there have also been a few attempts to develop robotic solutions for landmine detecting; the majority of proposed robotic solutions for landmine detecting, consists of either a 4-wheeled or tank like utility vehicle with some sort of metal detecting device mounted in the front of the vehicle. 

Nonetheless, most of the attempted solutions to develop a mine detecting robot pertain their respective flaws. Some designs are too big/heavy and can unintentionally detonate anti-personnel mines if it is not detected. Other designs are too small and cannot effectively perform its required tasks in rough terrain, such as heavy vegetation and/or rocky conditions, which is where most landmines are located [6]. Lastly, the most common gap noticed throughout all designs, is the ability for the robot to effectively perform its task regardless of its operating environment. If there is a region of high vegetation or rocks, a standard 4-wheeled or tank like device is most likely incapable of maneuvering through such environment, assuming that the device/vehicle is not overly sized to the point of self-detonating an anti-personnel landmine. Additionally, most proposed solutions to developing such robotic system includes the use of a basic metal detecting device fixed onto the robot; when in actuality, military and humanitarian demining personnel tend to rely on highly advanced metal detecting/GPR sensor fused devices to help increases their accuracy and decrease false alarms during demining operations. 

Thus, our proposed solution is to develop a low cost, low weight, and agile autonomous tank with four separate tracks. This design does not only increase the device's ability to perform effectively in rough terrain, but also has the potential of producing less pressure per track than the required amount of force needed to detonate an anti-personnel landmine (11lbs-35lbs) [5]. Moreover, our proposed solution will have an emphasis towards designing an adaptable mounting bracket for hand-held metal detectors to allow the operator to place any mine detecting device of their choice, within the robot's constraints. The autonomous abilities of the robot will be a behavior-based architecture that is based on layers with different levels of competence. The lowest layer is often in charge of avoiding obstacles, and upper layers contain other task-oriented behaviors. Typically, lower-level actions are given higher priority (to avoid obstacle is more important for the survival of the robot than to follow the defined path). The most top-level layer of a demining robot ought to be in charge of navigation. The robot is guided by the navigation layer along a predetermined path, ensuring coverage of a desired area. Through the use of the proper sensors, environmental restrictions should trigger lower-level behaviors that are in charge of avoiding obstacles and maintaining stability. It will be important to keep track of any deviations from the predetermined search path brought on by environmental factors. At the conclusion of the mission, the terrain's digital map should clearly indicate the areas that were searched and skipped, along with any mine targets that were discovered. [6]

Global System analysis

Global Need

As conveyed from the image to the left, the world is still experiencing an overwhelming amount of present and suspected territorial regions of anti-personnel landmines. If our proposed solution can at least help pave the way for more involvement from robotic manufacturers and research facilities to create advanced and large-scale robotic solutions to autonomous landmine detecting and extracting, this can greatly impact the world. Not only would this help prevent countless casualties of innocent civilians and children, but also assist in future construction and establishments on millions of acres of land where mines are currently presents and/or suspected.​​​

Local Need

The project is aimed at humanitarian and military organizations focused on demining such as those mentioned earlier. These organizations can benefit from our project because they will be able to utilize technology that protects and prevents the death/injury of their deminers exposed in the mine fields. Our system would be compatible with various types of terrain, from flat to heavy vegetation, allowing our users to adapt to different environments of these mine fields. The civilians and children surrounding these mine infested fields would be directly affected by our project as they would now have the freedom to travel or change locations as needed for them without having to adjust their plans due to local mine fields.

Potential Implications of Design

Positive

  • Create a safer environment
  • Prevent unnecessary deaths
  • Save money
  • Re-use of land 

Negative

  • Cause tensions
  • Accidental Detonation
  • Replace deminers' jobs

Plan to reduce the negative:

  • Develop a prototype that pertains emphasis on ease of use to reduce learning curve for user.
  • Constrain the total weight of our design to less than the average required weight needed to detonate anti-personnel mines.
  • Emphasize the decreases of potential casualties as well as the increase of efficiency in demining operations as a result of utilizing an autonomous robot to replace humans/animals in mine fields. 

RESULTING CONSTRAINTS AND CONSIDERATIONS

As mentioned above, there are solutions to develop a mine detection robot, but most of them are obtain their respective flaws. As aforementioned, some designs are too large or heavy and may unintentionally detonate antipersonnel mines if not detected, or others are too small and cannot effectively perform their tasks in realistic environments. Therefore, we decided to state our considerations and constraints for this project. 


The constraints that we must take into account are budget, time, stakeholder restrictions, regulations laws, and parameters for features and functionalities. On the other hand, the considerations we must focus on are the size and weight of the robot, the operating environment, price, duration, and durability.

Constraints

  • Budget: One of the most important constraints is the budget that they will provide us. To do the project, clients need to know how much it will cost so they can calculate if it is worth investing in the product.
  • Time: We have to focus on the time we manage to carry out the project. We have 5 months to create the mine-detecting robot.  
  • Stakeholders' restrictions: 

  1. The design must be agile enough to effectively perform in rough terrain
  2. Tracking abilities; robot should return its GPS location/path and detected anti-personnel mines.
  3. Must be remotely operated at a minimum.

  • Regulations Laws: ​​​​​​​Data Privacy rules: All information received by the mine-detecting robot has to be confidential and protected against cyber-attacks from external forces.
  • Features and Functionalities:

  1. Video feed of robot's vision using camera 
  2. Ability to return GPS location/path of robot and detected anti-personnel mines.
  3. Autonomous and path planning abilities

Considerations

  • Size and Weight: Realistic build should be no bigger than an actual military dog, such as a German Shepard, Vizsla, or Belgian Malinois. Our design should produce less pressure per wheel than required to amount of force detonate an anti-personnel landmine (11lbs-35lbs).
  • Operating environment: Most common mine fields are rough terrain environments such as high grass, inclinations, sand, and rocks. 
  • Price: ​​​​​​​Device contains the possibility of accidental detonation from an anti-personnel landmine; thus, replacement needs to be affordable
  • Duration and Robustness: Ideally, we want the battery life of the robot to last just as long (or longer) than a regular canine operation (~45min). Also, the material toughness and resistance to heat is a key factor since the robot will most likely be operated in environments that induce physical stress onto the robot.
  • Heat Resistance and Cooling System: We will have to take into consideration the average outdoor temperatures of common mine fields locations (such as Egypt, Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.) and the appropriate cooling system for components.

Copyright © 2023 Autonomous Vehicle for Landmine Detection  - All Rights Reserved.


This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept